Why Muntinlupa court allowed De Lima, others to post bail | ABS-CBN
ADVERTISEMENT
Welcome, Kapamilya! We use cookies to improve your browsing experience. Continuing to use this site means you agree to our use of cookies. Tell me more!
Spotlight
Why Muntinlupa court allowed De Lima, others to post bail
Why Muntinlupa court allowed De Lima, others to post bail
Mike Navallo,
ABS-CBN News
Published Nov 13, 2023 06:22 PM PHT
MANILA -- After more than 6 years and 8 months, detained former Senator Leila de Lima will finally walk free, although only temporarily, after a Muntinlupa court allowed her to post bail in the last drug case against her.
MANILA -- After more than 6 years and 8 months, detained former Senator Leila de Lima will finally walk free, although only temporarily, after a Muntinlupa court allowed her to post bail in the last drug case against her.
Muntinlupa RTC Branch 206 Judge Gener Gito reversed Judge Romeo Buenaventura’s previous denial of De Lima’s bail petition.
Muntinlupa RTC Branch 206 Judge Gener Gito reversed Judge Romeo Buenaventura’s previous denial of De Lima’s bail petition.
Aside from De Lima, her co-accused former Bureau of Corrections chief Franklin Bucayu, her former aides Ronnie Dayan and Joenel Sanchez, and Jad Dera, were allowed to post bail.
Aside from De Lima, her co-accused former Bureau of Corrections chief Franklin Bucayu, her former aides Ronnie Dayan and Joenel Sanchez, and Jad Dera, were allowed to post bail.
All of them were required to pay P300,000 each as bail.
All of them were required to pay P300,000 each as bail.
ADVERTISEMENT
In a 69-page ruling, Gito said the testimonies of the prosecution's 9 witnesses "were not able to clearly establish that there exists a conspiracy among them to commit illegal drug trading."
In a 69-page ruling, Gito said the testimonies of the prosecution's 9 witnesses "were not able to clearly establish that there exists a conspiracy among them to commit illegal drug trading."
In a 69-page ruling, Muntinlupa RTC Br 206 Judge Gener Gito says the testimonies of the prosecution's 9 witnesses "were not able to clearly establish that there exists a conspiracy among them to commit illegal drug trading." pic.twitter.com/AYyFFxCC3Z
— Mike Navallo (@mikenavallo) November 13, 2023
In a 69-page ruling, Muntinlupa RTC Br 206 Judge Gener Gito says the testimonies of the prosecution's 9 witnesses "were not able to clearly establish that there exists a conspiracy among them to commit illegal drug trading." pic.twitter.com/AYyFFxCC3Z
— Mike Navallo (@mikenavallo) November 13, 2023
Among the witnesses against De Lima was ret. PS/Supt. Jerry Valeroso, who claimed that he saw P65 million worth of drug money inside the kubol of a Chinese inmate.
Among the witnesses against De Lima was ret. PS/Supt. Jerry Valeroso, who claimed that he saw P65 million worth of drug money inside the kubol of a Chinese inmate.
The court said that even if true, this will not constitute direct/circumstantial evidence of common resolution to commit crime.
The court said that even if true, this will not constitute direct/circumstantial evidence of common resolution to commit crime.
The court also said the testimonies of other convicts do not establish conspiracy to commit illegal drug trading. These include:
The court also said the testimonies of other convicts do not establish conspiracy to commit illegal drug trading. These include:
- Nonito Arile
- Renante Diaz
- Engelberto Durano
- Noel Martinez
- Joel Capones
- Jojo Baligad
- Nonito Arile
- Renante Diaz
- Engelberto Durano
- Noel Martinez
- Joel Capones
- Jojo Baligad
The court also dismissed as "hearsay" the claim of the prosecution's most important witness, Herbert Colanggo, that he was raising funds for De Lima's senatorial bid.
The court also dismissed as "hearsay" the claim of the prosecution's most important witness, Herbert Colanggo, that he was raising funds for De Lima's senatorial bid.
It said the statement came from Sebastian, not De Lima.
It said the statement came from Sebastian, not De Lima.
The court also said that the testimony of Retired Gen. Benjamin Magalong, formerly head of PNP Criminal Investigation and Detection Group, will not establish conspiracy to commit illegal drug trading among the accused.
The court also said that the testimony of Retired Gen. Benjamin Magalong, formerly head of PNP Criminal Investigation and Detection Group, will not establish conspiracy to commit illegal drug trading among the accused.
On the contrary, it confirmed De Lima's lack of involvement in the illegal drug trading at the New Bilibid Prison.
On the contrary, it confirmed De Lima's lack of involvement in the illegal drug trading at the New Bilibid Prison.
The court added that the prosecution failed to present evidence to prove individual acts of the accused that when combined, will prove complicity.
The court added that the prosecution failed to present evidence to prove individual acts of the accused that when combined, will prove complicity.
Only Jaybee Sebastian was proven to have committed illegal drug trading, according to the court, but evidential link between him and De Lima and other accused was not established.
Only Jaybee Sebastian was proven to have committed illegal drug trading, according to the court, but evidential link between him and De Lima and other accused was not established.
"Assessing the totality of evidence presented by the prosecution, the Court is of the firm view that accused De Lima, Bucayu, Dayan, Sanchez and Dera should be allowed to post bail as the prosecution was not able to discharge its burden of establishing that guilt of said accused is strong," the court said.
"Assessing the totality of evidence presented by the prosecution, the Court is of the firm view that accused De Lima, Bucayu, Dayan, Sanchez and Dera should be allowed to post bail as the prosecution was not able to discharge its burden of establishing that guilt of said accused is strong," the court said.
RELATED VIDEO
Read More:
Leila de Lima
De Lima bail
Gener Gito
Romeo Buenaventura
Franklin Bucayu
Ronnie Dayan
Joenel Sanchez
Jad Dera
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT