US think-tank warns PH vs forging deal with China | ABS-CBN
ADVERTISEMENT
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d998c/d998c1524ae866bbfc56e1b62cdd0cb7fd561a9f" alt="dpo-dps-seal"
Welcome, Kapamilya! We use cookies to improve your browsing experience. Continuing to use this site means you agree to our use of cookies. Tell me more!
US think-tank warns PH vs forging deal with China
US think-tank warns PH vs forging deal with China
Ron Gagalac,
ABS-CBN News
Published Feb 03, 2017 05:13 PM PHT
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/77780/77780a076c8489ad4c0d176e4c6b7cc1eb0d0eea" alt="Clipboard"
A Washington DC-based think-tank cautions the Philippines against negotiating with China and striking a deal that might create imbalances in diplomatic relations along the ASEAN region, and a defense strategy expert warns of a military conflict if no deals will be reached.
A Washington DC-based think-tank cautions the Philippines against negotiating with China and striking a deal that might create imbalances in diplomatic relations along the ASEAN region, and a defense strategy expert warns of a military conflict if no deals will be reached.
Murray Hiebert, senior advisor and deputy director for Southeast Asia program of the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), said China is poised to fight out its claim on the South China Sea head on with other claimant countries.
Murray Hiebert, senior advisor and deputy director for Southeast Asia program of the Center for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), said China is poised to fight out its claim on the South China Sea head on with other claimant countries.
"China is determined to keep its position as the dominant player in the South China Sea. I'm not sure that there is much to negotiate," Hiebert said.
"China is determined to keep its position as the dominant player in the South China Sea. I'm not sure that there is much to negotiate," Hiebert said.
He said it will be tough for the Philippines to bargain by itself, considering that the country is currently in a very weak position to demand anything from China after its falling out with the US, while turning its allegiance to Beijing.
He said it will be tough for the Philippines to bargain by itself, considering that the country is currently in a very weak position to demand anything from China after its falling out with the US, while turning its allegiance to Beijing.
ADVERTISEMENT
"It's gonna be tough especially for the Philippines to bargain by itself, it's in a very weak position. I think by working with Vietnam, Malaysia and Brunei, I think you could have gotten more. But I think dealing with himself, the Chinese are very good at this stuff," he said.
"It's gonna be tough especially for the Philippines to bargain by itself, it's in a very weak position. I think by working with Vietnam, Malaysia and Brunei, I think you could have gotten more. But I think dealing with himself, the Chinese are very good at this stuff," he said.
MORE HARDWARE
MORE HARDWARE
The CSIS Southeast Asia Program director said the next thing China could do is build more infrastructure and send more military hardware to tighten its claim on these islands in the west Philippine sea.
The CSIS Southeast Asia Program director said the next thing China could do is build more infrastructure and send more military hardware to tighten its claim on these islands in the west Philippine sea.
"Move more airplanes, move more ships to the reclaimed islands, but I think China is gonna try to keep it a little bit quiet this year," he said,
"Move more airplanes, move more ships to the reclaimed islands, but I think China is gonna try to keep it a little bit quiet this year," he said,
"Taiwan and North Korea will be a bigger issue for China and the United States."
"Taiwan and North Korea will be a bigger issue for China and the United States."
http://sa.kapamilya.com/absnews/abscbnnews/media/news-special1/world/8/9/hangar2.jpg
http://sa.kapamilya.com/absnews/abscbnnews/media/news-special1/world/8/9/hangar2.jpg
Hiebert also said that it will be good for the Philippines to have the basic backing of ASEAN, and work together in tandem with the Vietnamese and Malaysians.
Hiebert also said that it will be good for the Philippines to have the basic backing of ASEAN, and work together in tandem with the Vietnamese and Malaysians.
"You'll be on a much stronger position, because the Chinese have a lot more at stake with Vietnam and Malaysia. Far more investments, far more business. What can the Philippines bargain with the Chinese?" he said.
"You'll be on a much stronger position, because the Chinese have a lot more at stake with Vietnam and Malaysia. Far more investments, far more business. What can the Philippines bargain with the Chinese?" he said.
NEW WORLD ORDER
NEW WORLD ORDER
Dr. Marvin Ott, strategic defense expert from John Hopkins University in Washington DC, meanwhile, believes that China is now on the verge of creating a new international order.
Dr. Marvin Ott, strategic defense expert from John Hopkins University in Washington DC, meanwhile, believes that China is now on the verge of creating a new international order.
"China will be the dominant power in Asia. The US will respect that. The US will recognize that the USA-Asia is over, and the Chinese day has arrived," Ott said.
"China will be the dominant power in Asia. The US will respect that. The US will recognize that the USA-Asia is over, and the Chinese day has arrived," Ott said.
"If I'm Chinese, that's what the Philippines should agree to, and if you do, we'll all live happily ever after."
"If I'm Chinese, that's what the Philippines should agree to, and if you do, we'll all live happily ever after."
Ott said it is unlikely that military conflict will arise if and when US President Donald Trump continues with the foreign policy of the Obama administration that there should be freedom of navigation in the South China Sea. But Ott does not discount the possibility that a war could erupt in the islands being claimed by Beijing.
Ott said it is unlikely that military conflict will arise if and when US President Donald Trump continues with the foreign policy of the Obama administration that there should be freedom of navigation in the South China Sea. But Ott does not discount the possibility that a war could erupt in the islands being claimed by Beijing.
"It will be so destructive to both sides, and because both sides have such tremendous relationship. The economic ties between the two are just massive. But when I say dangerous, yes, it has a potential for military clash," Ott said.
"It will be so destructive to both sides, and because both sides have such tremendous relationship. The economic ties between the two are just massive. But when I say dangerous, yes, it has a potential for military clash," Ott said.
Ott explained that the US response to China's increasing building of islands and patrols has been what the Pentagon calls the "freedom of navigation operations" or FONOPS, where the US deploys naval ships along the maritime territory that China is claiming.
Ott explained that the US response to China's increasing building of islands and patrols has been what the Pentagon calls the "freedom of navigation operations" or FONOPS, where the US deploys naval ships along the maritime territory that China is claiming.
"The idea was the Chinese will be impressed and therefore would stand back but the Chinese have not been impressed and they have not stood back," he said.
"The idea was the Chinese will be impressed and therefore would stand back but the Chinese have not been impressed and they have not stood back," he said.
"My interpretation is that the FONOPS, the freedom of navigation operations, have not been effective in terms of having the strategic security outcome that the planners have hoped. Now you have to think of what's next, and that's where it gets very tough and very dangerous," he added.
"My interpretation is that the FONOPS, the freedom of navigation operations, have not been effective in terms of having the strategic security outcome that the planners have hoped. Now you have to think of what's next, and that's where it gets very tough and very dangerous," he added.
Ott said the tarnished relations between US and the Philippines, as evident in the tirades of Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte against former US President Barack Obama and the Americans, undermined the defense strategies of several Asian countries and that of the US.
Ott said the tarnished relations between US and the Philippines, as evident in the tirades of Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte against former US President Barack Obama and the Americans, undermined the defense strategies of several Asian countries and that of the US.
"We have replaced in a very short time a very high level of strategic certainty and collaboration, with a huge level of uncertainty, and this is against the backdrop of an increasing Chinese military aggressiveness, and that uncertainty becomes dangerous. This is a very dangerous situation," he said.
"We have replaced in a very short time a very high level of strategic certainty and collaboration, with a huge level of uncertainty, and this is against the backdrop of an increasing Chinese military aggressiveness, and that uncertainty becomes dangerous. This is a very dangerous situation," he said.
"If I'm Filipino and in Manila, I have a very large question in my mind whether President Duterte understands what are the geo-political interests of the Philippines actually are in the South China Sea," he added.
"If I'm Filipino and in Manila, I have a very large question in my mind whether President Duterte understands what are the geo-political interests of the Philippines actually are in the South China Sea," he added.
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT