US Navy destroyer sunk in World War II is found 20,000 feet under the sea

Neil Vigdor, The New York Times

Posted at Nov 06 2019 08:42 AM

A photo provided by Vulcan Inc. shows what researchers believe to be the wreckage of the USS Johnston. Seventy-five years after the Battle of Leyte Gulf, the largest naval battle of World War II, a private underwater expedition discovered the wreckage. Vulcan Inc. via The New York Times

It was a mismatch — a small task unit of U.S. Navy ships confronted by a mighty squadron of Japanese warships.

The Americans went on the attack with every gun and torpedo that they had, repelling the enemy vessels that had threatened to cut off the supply lines for an amphibious landing led by Gen. Douglas MacArthur on the strategic island of Leyte in the Philippines.

But the heroic stand in the Battle of Leyte Gulf, the largest naval battle of World War II, came at a heavy cost: Two escort carriers, two destroyers and a destroyer escort from the task force unit, known as Taffy 3, sank.

Now, 75 years after that turning point in the Pacific theater, a private underwater expedition discovered the wreckage of one of those destroyers, which researchers believe to be the USS Johnston DD-557.

The Fletcher-class destroyer lost 186 members of its crew of 327 sailors, including its commander, Ernest E. Evans, who was the first Native American in the Navy to receive the Medal of Honor. It sank on Oct. 25, 1944.

“They were hopelessly outclassed, but they fought anyway,” said Sam Cox, a retired Navy rear admiral and director of the Naval History and Heritage Command, the preservation arm of the Navy.

Navy historians confirmed that the wreckage belonged to a Fletcher-class destroyer, but said that they needed to do more research to determine if it was the USS Johnston or the USS Hoel DD-533, which sank on the same day.

Two 5-inch gun mounts, two funnels, a propeller shaft and twisted hunks of metal are part of a debris field that was found in May by the Research Vessel Petrel in a trench 20,400 feet beneath the surface of the Philippine Sea.

It is the deepest warship wreck ever discovered, according to researchers, who used a remote operated vehicle to conduct an underwater survey.

At that depth, there was a danger of losing the remote-operated vehicle because of the lack of buoyancy, which forced its operator to thrust the vehicle upward.

“During this dive, our deepest yet, we encountered challenges that impacted our ability to operate and obtain the typical, high quality survey that we strive for,” said Paul Mayer, a pilot of the remote-operated vehicle and researcher.

The underwater survey was conducted by Vulcan Inc., the RV Petrel’s owner and operator, which released video footage of the wreckage last week to coincide with the 75th anniversary of the USS Johnston’s sinking and to try to get confirmation that it was the destroyer that was discovered.

The private company was started by Paul Allen, a late Microsoft co-founder, and his sister, Jody Allen, to handle the family’s business and philanthropic activities, including underwater research.

More than 30 sunken warships have been discovered by Vulcan researchers, including a number of U.S. vessels lost in World War II, like the USS Indianapolis, the USS Wasp and the USS Hornet.

So few photos remain of the USS Johnston, according to Cox, who said both the Johnston and the Hoel performed with extreme heroism during the Battle of Leyte Gulf.

“The position would make more sense that it’s the Johnston where they found it,” Cox said. “That’s among the deepest places in the entire ocean.”

Cox said the Navy and Vulcan Inc. had worked collaboratively on a number of projects.

“They respect that they don’t disturb the wrecks at all and they don’t publicize the exact coordinates,” he said.

Had the Japanese squadron overtaken the American task unit, Taffy 3, and cut off the troop and supply ships for MacArthur’s invasion, the consequences would have been dire, Cox said. As the Johnston was sinking, the crew of a Japanese destroyer saluted the vessel, he said.

“They didn’t think Americans had that kind of bravery,” he said, “so that surprised them.”