Paula White, newest White House aide, is a uniquely Trumpian pastor

Jeremy W. Peters and Elizabeth Dias, The New York Times

Posted at Nov 04 2019 05:29 PM

Paula White, newest White House aide, is a uniquely Trumpian pastor 1
Paula White, the televangelist and longtime friend of Donald Trump, in Washington, Jan. 18, 2017. White, based in Florida and personal pastor to President Trump whom he has known since 2002, has joined the Trump administration in an official capacity, according to a White House official. Sam Hodgson, The New York Times

Dwight D. Eisenhower and Richard M. Nixon turned to Billy Graham, the evangelist so ubiquitous he was known as America’s Preacher. Barack Obama turned to Rick Warren, the author of "The Purpose Driven Life," which was the best-selling nonfiction hardback in U.S. history after the Bible.

Donald Trump has a televangelist from Florida: Paula White, an outsider whose populist brand of Christianity mirrors Trump’s conquest of the Republican Party. And she is in many ways a quintessentially Trump figure: a television preacher, married three times, who lives in a mansion.

For years he has called her his longtime friend and personal pastor. When he ran for president in 2016, he turned to her to drive his evangelical support. And on Thursday the White House confirmed that White had officially joined the administration to advise Trump’s Faith and Opportunity Initiative, which aims to give religious groups more of a voice in government programs devoted to issues like defending religious liberty and fighting poverty.

Her new role gives her a formal seat at the table as Trump tries to ensure that evangelicals — the foundation of his political base — remain united behind him in his bid to win a second term. As a liaison to Trump, White has regularly facilitated meetings for conservative pastors and White House officials, assuring the president’s core constituencies that he addresses their interests.

Among Christians, however, White is a divisive figure. Her association with the belief that God wants followers to find wealth and health — commonly called the prosperity gospel — is highly unorthodox in the faith and considered heretical by many. And experts on religion in politics said that White’s ascendancy was unlike any other relationship between a president and a faith adviser in modern times.

"I never would have guessed that Paula White and Donald Trump would be the preacher-president duo people remember like Billy Graham and Richard Nixon," said Kate Bowler, a professor of Christian history at Duke Divinity School.

"Paula White survived scandal and little support from the religious right to become one of the only stand-alone women in the male-dominated world of televangelism," Bowler said. "She has done what no one thought she could do, scraping out a place for an unpopular theology beside an unpopular president."

White’s rise to greater prominence and influence in evangelical circles is strikingly similar to Trump’s rise among Republicans. Both were outsiders who often faced suspicion and scorn from more conventional, established leaders of the spheres in which they sought acceptance. And both survived accusations of financial misconduct and ethical improprieties.

White, who also goes by White-Cain after her marriage to Jonathan Cain, the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame keyboardist for Journey, did not respond to requests for an interview.

Some argue that by elevating figures like White, Trump is undermining Christianity in the same way he has damaged the Republican Party.

The move is “a very ominous sign” and signals that “Christian narcissism” has come into the White House, said the Rev. William J. Barber II, who organized the Moral Mondays protests in North Carolina and who spoke at the Democratic National Convention in 2016.

"The so-called prosperity gospel is a false gospel," he said, comparing it to a theology that justified slavery because of economic prosperity. "It is an attempt to interpret the gospel to be primarily about personal wealth and personal power, which is contrary to the theology of Jesus where the good news was always focused on caring for the poor, the least of these, the stranger, the sick."

But her appeal with some religious Christians helps Trump reach audiences that are not naturally inclined to support him.

Although hard to quantify, White’s influence in less politically active evangelical circles, including among televangelists and viewers of the popular Trinity Broadcasting Network, appeared to help Trump in 2016.

Most polls focused on Trump’s white evangelical or Roman Catholic support, but conservative political strategists also capitalized on his marginal support in Christian subsets, like some Hispanic and African American charismatic churches. But in a sign of how unpopular Trump remains with African Americans, several hundred people from White’s heavily African American congregation left her church because of her association with him.

Trump’s candidacy had initially divided evangelical leaders, with many prominent social conservatives supporting candidates like Sens. Ted Cruz of Texas and Marco Rubio of Florida during the Republican primary. Trump largely skirted the traditional Washington evangelical apparatus and instead surrounded himself with outsider figures who had amassed popular, if not traditionally political, influence, like White and the Liberty University president, Jerry Falwell Jr.

When it became clear that Trump would be the likely nominee, the two Christian factions came to a détente after two meetings one day in New York, largely around Trump’s support for anti-abortion policies, religious liberty and persecuted Christians in the Middle East. White, as the pastor personally closest to Trump, became a key liaison.

Darrell Scott, a pastor of a largely African American church in Cleveland who supports Trump, said that White had been "active" in African American and pentecostal circles for decades.

Tony Perkins, president of the Family Research Council who considers himself a more traditional conservative Christian, said that Trump had cooked up an "evangelical gumbo" by bringing together people from parts of Christianity that would ordinarily never intersect.

"I didn’t know Paula White before," he said. "She came from a different stream than I’d probably swim in." But as they’ve become close over the last three years, he said, he and other evangelicals who are not aligned with her theologically have come to realize their role with this administration is the same. "We’re there to influence public policy and move this nation forward where faith is openly welcomed, so that you don’t have to hide the fact that you’re a person of faith," he said.

Push by evangelicals helped set stage for Trump decision on Jerusalem

White has become a regular in Washington, organizing frequent meetings for pastors around the country to meet with administration officials. When Trump met with his informal evangelical advisory coalition this week, she was seated at his right hand.

This past March she helped facilitate a meeting at the White House with Vice President Mike Pence for 100 Hispanic pastors and denominational leaders, said Tony Suarez, the executive vice president of the National Hispanic Christian Leaders Conference, a network of 40,000 Hispanic evangelical congregations.

White led a pentecostal-leaning church, recently renamed City of Destiny, with thousands of members near Orlando, Florida. She stepped down as senior pastor in May and announced plans to start a university and 3,000 new churches. In 2007, Sen. Charles E. Grassley, R-Iowa, and the Senate Finance Committee had investigated her ministry’s tax-exempt status, but the investigation was eventually dropped.

White first met Trump in 2002, when he called her after seeing her preach on a Christian televangelist program. They stayed in touch, she bought an apartment in his 502 Park Avenue building, and he reportedly attended Bible studies she occasionally led in New York.

He invited her to attend the first season finale of his show “The Apprentice,” where she prayed with the cast and crew before the live taping.

She prayed with him before he went onstage to accept the Republican nomination for president in Cleveland. She became the first clergywoman to lead an inaugural prayer when he took the oath of office, according to Trump’s inauguration committee.

Her employment at the White House raises questions about whether she may be putting her church’s tax-exempt status in question, as churches are not allowed to engage in overt political activity. Though she has stepped down as the pastor, she could run into difficulty with the Internal Revenue Service if she remained active in the church, even in an informal role, while working for the president.

"My sense is if she is leaving her church position and making a clean break that there would be no IRS problem," said Fred Wertheimer, president of Democracy 21, a campaign finance watchdog. But, he added, “If she is continuing in an official public role for the church while working in the White House, that would cause a tax status problem as she would be using the church for political purposes.”

Asked if White had divested her financial stake in the church, a White House spokesman said they would not comment on personnel. White will not take a salary, according to another White House spokesman.

The divisions about the meaning of Christianity are a point of contention headed into a heated general election, where Democrats are putting Trump’s vision of morality on trial.

"I get asked this question all the time — how can these Christians support Donald Trump when so much that he says and does is literally antithetical to the person and teachings of Jesus?" said Jim Wallis, a progressive evangelical who has challenged the conservative wing of his church for decades.

"White nationalism isn’t just racist, it’s anti-Christ," Wallis added.

Like many of the president’s most devoted followers, White insists that he is not fazed by the attacks on him. The impeachment inquiry, she said in a recent interview with The New York Post, “wears on him.” But as for his reelection, she said, “I’ve never seen the base more energized than it is now.”