Turkey begins life under strict social media rules

Fulya Ozerkan, Agence France-Presse

Posted at Oct 01 2020 10:58 AM

Turkey begins life under strict social media rules 1
A woman wearing a protective face mask travels on a ferry over the Bosphorus as the outbreak of the coronavirus disease (COVID-19) continues, in Istanbul, Turkey, Sept. 30, 2020. Murad Sezer, Reuters

ISTANBUL - Turkey on Thursday enters a new era of tight social media restrictions that threaten to erase the local presence of Facebook and Twitter should they fail to take down contentious posts.

The legislation was rammed through parliament by President Recep Tayyip Erdogan's ruling AKP party and follows the government's crackdown on opposition newspapers and television channels.

Facebook's human rights officer Iain Levine tweeted that it "raises many concerns (about) human rights".

But while fearful, free speech advocates are not certain whether Erdogan's government will be able to implement the law's most punitive measures -- or if social media companies will ever fully comply.

"We believe that these days it's really impossible in a country like Turkey to suppress social media -- it is so much a part of people's lives," said Emma Sinclair-Webb, the Turkey director of Human Rights Watch.

Under the new rules, platforms with more than 1 million daily users must open offices in Turkey that can deal with local court decisions to remove offending content within 48 hours.

If not, they face advertising bans, fines of up to 40 million Turkish lira ($5.1 million), and -- crucially -- bandwidth reductions of up to 90 percent, making the platforms effectively unusable.

They also require social media companies to "take necessary measures" to store user data locally, although binding legislation to that effect was taken out of the final version of the draft law passed in July.


Erdogan has made no secret of his disdain for social media, although his @RTErdogan Twitter account has 16.7 million followers. 

"Twitter schmitter!" he declared in 2014, vowing to "wipe all of these" platforms out.

He followed through on his threat by briefly unplugging Twitter and YouTube ahead of local elections later that year which came during an online audio tapes scandal implicating his inner circle in an alleged corruption scandal.

"The objective of the law is to threaten social media companies with a comply-or-die message," Sinclair-Webb told AFP.

Access to websites and content has already been partially restricted in the nation of 83 million people.

Twitter last year listed Turkey -- along with Russia and Japan -- among the top 3 countries responsible for 86 percent of all requests to take down posts.

Privacy rights advocate Sevket Uyanik said Turkey had blocked access to 408,000 websites, 40,000 tweets, 10,000 YouTube videos and 6,200 Facebook posts by the end of 2019.

"When this is already the case, imagine what it will be like after October 1," Uyanik told AFP.

Both Facebook and Twitter refused to comment when asked by AFP if they would comply with the new rules.


Erdogan is openly suspicious of the internet and once branded Twitter a "menace" for helping mobilize 2013 anti-government protests, which threw up one of the biggest challenges to his party's rule.

Many Turks, especially the young, get much of their news on social media since most of the regular news outlets are owned or controlled by pro-government companies.

"There are a lot of cases of domestic violence against women and murders that we don't see on TV," Ayse Nur Akyuz, a model and self-described "influencer" with 47,000 Instagram followers, told AFP.

"News about them spreads on social media in 5 minutes."

Everyone from high school students, cartoonists and reporters to a former Miss Turkey model have landed in court for tweets and other social media posts deemed offensive to the president.

The new legislation gained momentum after Erdogan became enraged in July by online insults of Finance Minister Berat Albayrak and his wife Esra, the president's daughter, following the birth of their fourth child.

Yet Sinclair-Webb noted that government supporters have also grown to depend on social media -- especially in the era of coronavirus restrictions and public gathering bans.

"Closing it down will not be a popular move," said Sinclair-Webb. "If it attempts to implement this new law, the government would also shoot itself in the foot."