Will gov't to bare drug war records? 'We don’t care about impression,' says Palace


Posted at Sep 16 2021 05:49 PM | Updated as of Sep 16 2021 06:21 PM

This photo taken July 8, 2021 shows workers wearing masks, gloves and protective coats as they carry a body bag 5 the skeletal remains of Rodzon Enriquez, who was killed five years ago in the country's war on drugs, after they were exhumed at a cemetery in Manila. Jam Sta. Rosa, Agence France-Presse/File
This photo taken July 8, 2021 shows workers wearing masks, gloves and protective coats as they carry a body bag 5 the skeletal remains of Rodzon Enriquez, who was killed five years ago in the country's war on drugs, after they were exhumed at a cemetery in Manila. Jam Sta. Rosa, Agence France-Presse/File

MANILA — Officials "don’t care about impression," Malacañang said on Thursday, when asked if it would release records of President Rodrigo Duterte's war on drugs to the Commission on Human Rights and the public.

Duterte's aides have said he would not cooperate with the International Criminal Court in its probe into his anti-narcotics campaign, after its judges found that a crime against humanity may have been committed under the crackdown where thousands have died.

Asked if government could make public its drug war records instead, Duterte's spokesman Harry Roque said, "We don’t care about impression. We care about the fact that the pillars of the criminal justice system are working."

"Why would I care about transparency when we’re ensuring that guilty individuals are investigated, prosecuted, and punished for their acts?" said Roque, a former human rights lawyer, in a press briefing.

"'Yon ang important kasi ang obligasyon ng estado (that is what's important because the obligation of the state) when there is violation of a right is to provide adequate legal remedy to the victims," continued the President's spokesman.

Duterte in June refused to give the justice department access to all police records on anti-drug operations. He said these are classified information that could affect national security.

The police said it would give the agency access to records of at least 53 drug operations where it found lapses on the part of the police. 

"Ang importante kasi, DOJ kasi DOJ sa ating sistemang legal ang magsasampa ng kaso. Walang kapangyarihang magsampa ng kaso ang CHR," said Roque.(What is important is the DOJ because in our legal system, it's the DOH that will file cases. The CHR has no power to file cases.)

Video courtesy of PTV 

ICC judges authorized Wednesday a full-blown investigation into Duterte's anti-narcotics campaign, which rights groups estimate has killed tens of thousands of people, saying it resembled an illegitimate and systematic attack on civilians.

Duterte "will not cooperate since first of all, the Philippines has left the Rome Statute, so the ICC no longer has jurisdiction over the country", chief presidential legal counsel Salvador Panelo told a radio station earlier Thursday.

"The government will not let in any ICC member to collect information and evidence here in the Philippines. They will be barred entry."

Duterte pulled Manila out of the Hague-based court after it launched a preliminary probe, but the ICC said it had jurisdiction over crimes committed while the Philippines was still a member.

Rights groups, lawyers and relatives of people killed in the drug war welcomed the ICC decision.

"I'm glad because this might be a way for us to get justice for the deaths of our loved ones," said Corazon Enriquez, who blames Duterte for the killing of her son during a police raid of their home in 2016.

"That's what we're hoping for— for that person responsible for the deaths of our children and family members to pay."

Edre Olalia, president of the National Union of Peoples' Lawyers, said the organization hoped this was "the beginning of the end to impunity" while rights group Karapatan said: "Duterte and his cohorts should be made accountable for these crimes".


Duterte was elected in 2016 on a campaign promise to get rid of the Philippines' drug problem, openly ordering police to kill drug suspects if officers' lives were in danger.

At least 6,181 people have died in more than 200,000 anti-drug operations conducted since July 2016, according to the latest official data released by the Philippines.

ICC prosecutors in court papers estimate the figure to be between 12,000 to 30,000 dead.

Duterte has repeatedly attacked the world's only permanent war crimes court, calling it "bulls***" and vowing not to cooperate with its probe.

Roque said Thursday Duterte had "no reaction" to the ICC announcement.

"From the start he has said he will die first before he will face foreign judges," Roque told reporters.

"If there are complaints, they have to be adjudged in the Philippines because our courts are functioning, and the ICC court has no jurisdiction."

Watch more on iWantTFC

But the country's top judges disagreed, ruling earlier this year that the ICC can prosecute "government actors" for alleged crimes committed before the nation withdrew from the tribunal.

The ICC said there was "reasonable basis" to believe that the crime against humanity of murder had been committed in the crackdown.

Its investigation will also cover alleged extra-judicial killings in the southern Davao region between 2011 and 2016, when Duterte was mayor.

"If he's guilty, he should be held accountable," said Santos Reario, a barber in the capital Manila.

"Maybe that's why he's planning to run for vice president— to escape accountability."

Duterte, barred under the constitution from seeking a second term, declared last month he will run for the country's second-highest office next year.

Critics said the move was partly driven by fear of criminal charges, though there is debate over whether the vice president enjoys legal immunity.

Human rights lawyer Kristina Conti told AFP the ICC investigation could take months or even years.

The government's refusal to cooperate would make the probe "hard," but she said ICC prosecutors could work with groups on the ground to get the evidence they needed.

Families said they were prepared to wait.

"Even if it will take a long time, at least we have something to look forward to instead of just waiting for nothing," said one victim's mother, who asked not to be identified.

"At least we have hope."

— With reports from Cecil Morella and Ron Lopez, Agence France-Presse