RP poll automation faces risks: IT experts


by Manny Mogato, Reuters | 09/11/2009 9:02 PM

Vulnerable to hacking, power outages, physical threats

MANILA - Automated elections in the Philippines next year could fail due to potential threats from hackers and other technical vulnerabilities, officials and information technology experts said on Friday.
  
The Philippines, seeking to overhaul an election process in which winners are declared months after the actual vote and allegations of fraud abound, will introduce a poll automation system that has never been tested anywhere in the world.

"It's vulnerable to attacks," Virtus Gil, a retired general and head of the government's cybersecurity agency, told Reuters, though he said there was no fool-proof electronic voting system in the world.

He urged the elections body to heed warnings from experts and assure the public that safety guarantees were available to protect the integrity of the polls.

"Electronic voting also increases the potential for large-scale fraud," Gil added.

On Thursday, the country's Supreme Court voted to uphold the $150 million deal between the Commission on Elections and a Barbados-based company to supply 82,200 machines to speed up counting of votes and minimise possible fraud.

Midas Marquez, court spokesman, said the court denied a petition to nullify the contract because the voting machine supplier met the minimum demands of the poll automation law.
  
Dante Mara, an expert who designs computer security systems, said power outages, hacking, overloading and physical threats could disrupt the whole process from the counting to the tallying and transmission of vote results.

"This early, approximately 3,800 to 4,200 precincts cannot be covered by the automated election system," Mara told reporters, saying these voting centres -- about 5 percent of the total number of precincts -- were inaccessible due to rugged terrain and lacked power.
  
Jose Tolentino, executive director of the poll agency, said the agency has to strengthen its security protocols, using a 128-bit encryption system to make hacking difficult.
  
"You will need 1 trillion combinations before you can grab the data we are transmitting," Tolentino said.
  
Lawmakers, political groups and analysts fear chaos from automated polls due to potential machine breakdowns and delays in result transmission, which could lead to a failed election and political limbo.

as of 09/11/2009 10:29 PM



Nonsense!

This is "millenium bug scare" being resurrected.

1) Are experts aware that one can't hack a standalone PCOS with no live remote access? Unless of course if the hacker is allowed to hijack the machine and break it up, which is impossible!

2) Are they aware that while it's possible to intercept election data during the transmission phase, all the hacker gets is only a copy but he still needs to gain access into the Comelec servers to corrupt the database?

3) And why harp on technical vulnerabilities? What's so technical about an enhanced scanning machine? Since this simple scanning task is done nationwide, problem is really more on delay or breakdown of communication lines during the transmission of election data, but the casting of votes would have already been successfully done by then, which is the most important aspect of election automation (AES).

Indeed, it's better for us to risk this "millenium bug scare" than to risk electing fake government officials after May 10, 2010. There's so much corruption already and we don't deserve another Hello Garci administration!



Pessimism sucks!

lintik tong mga katulad ni 'sisid marino' na toh! masyado kayong magagaling dumakdak eh di ikaw kaya mag-bigay ng paraan paano ma-papabuti ang election sa pinas. panay ka negative, panay sisi sa iba. langya bakit nasa IT ka ba? abugado ka ba?. imbes na suportahan ang pag-asenso, panay arte at reklamo ang binabato. kung ako sa'yo magabantay ka nalang ng boto pagdating ng halalan ng may mabuti kang magawa kung ayaw mo naman eh di lumayas ka na sa pinas!



BE POSITIVE

BAKIT PO TAYO NAGBIBIGAY NEGATIVE NA EXPECTATION SA AUTOMATED ELECTION SYTEM SC JUSTICES KNEW THEIR JOBS @ NAJUSTIFY NGA NILA NA WELL DONE ANG AES AS PER SUPPORTED DOCUMENTS AT PROPER BIDDING ANG DINAANAN NYAN BAKIT ANG SMARTMATIC BA AY MAGPAPABAYA BA NG KANILANG SIDE TUNGKOL DYAN SA HACKER SYIMPRE MAY PANGKONTRA DYAN KAYA ANG DAPAT GAWIN NATIN MGA FILIPINO NA MAGMATYAG,MAGKAISA @ PUMILI NG KANDIDATO NA KARAPAT DAPAT @ HUWAG NANG MAGBULAG BULAGAN SA MGA NANGYYAYARI SA BANSA NATIN KAGAYA NG VOTE BUYING NA SYANG PINAKAUGAT NG PANDARAYA KASI ANG UGALI NI JUAN DE LA CRUZ AY KUNG SINO ANG MKAKABUHAY NG MAGANDA SA KANYANG SARILI AY YUN ANG KANYANG PAPABURAN NA ANG DAPAT GAWIN AY YUNG NAKAKAGANDA NG BUHAY SA NAKAKARAMI OR SA BANSANG PILIPINAS YUN ANG DAPAT..........



Your Dumb Marino

SC justices are not that dumb as you think. I think you are the one who is dumb. ahaha They certainly need to learn about this stuff. Maybe you are thinking that because most of them are old then they don't know nothing about IT. Silly you. Aside from that, it is only their job to interpret the law and decide when there is conflict in its understanding. and not make the law. Better read before you make your comments here okay.



HELLO GARCI! HELLO GARCI! NAGKAUSAP NA BA KAYO NI ABALOS?

Nagaaksaya lang kayo ng panahon at pera diyan, tagos na sa buto ng Pilipino ang kadayaan oy! Huwag na ninyong gayahin yung ibang bansa na malinis ang halalan sapagka't manalo man yung malinis, marumi pa rin ang mga kasama niya sa gobyerno! Kayong nasa Korte Suprema, ano ba ang naiintindihan ninyo diyan sa poll automation? Kumunsulta ba kayo sa mga IT Expert bago kayo nagpapasiya?

Pasiya ng pasiya hindi naman pala alam na magagawa ding dayain ng mga matatalino at nagsipag aral na Pinoy. Baka nagsisimba pa nga ang mga iyan pero pinagbibili naman ang mga sarili dun sa gustong mandaya.

MAGKITA KITA NA LANG KAY0 SA SIMBAHAN AT ISANGGUNI SA PARE KUNG ANO ANG MAGANDANG PANALANGIN PARA LUMINIS ANG INYONG MGA PAGIISIP.



Nation Video


More Videos


Tower 1


Tower 2


Storypage Ad zedo