Some US restaurants forgo tips

By Juliette Michel, Agence France-Presse

Posted at May 06 2014 03:27 PM | Updated as of May 06 2014 11:27 PM

NEW YORK -- In the United States, customers are expected to add an extra 10 to 20 percent to their tab at the end of a meal, but some restaurants are forgoing these tips.

Leaving a gratuity is de rigueur when dining out because pay for restaurant servers is so low.

While the US federal minimum wage is $7.25 an hour, wait staff can legally be paid as little as $2.13 in some places. In New York, one of the most expensive US cities, salaries for waiters start at $5 per hour.

For wait staff, tips help bolster pay in line with other restaurant workers who don't receive gratuities.

However there is a new trend: Riki Restaurant in New York is one of a number of establishments eliminating tips by taking the unusual step of paying their staff higher wages.

"Riki Restaurant is now a non-tipping establishment," read notices at the popular Japanese eatery. "Tipping is not required nor expected."

Protection from customers' whims

The no-tip policy is being adopted especially by some upscale restaurants where clients are less price sensitive, said Michael Lynn, a professor at Cornell University's School of Hotel Administration.

But a downside of the no-tipping policy is indeed that the sticker shock that patrons sometimes suffer when perusing menus that have tips already factored into the prices

"It makes a restaurant look more expensive than a restaurant that has 15 percent lower prices, but expects tips," said Lynn, who specializes a professor at Cornell University's School of Hotel Administration. in issues related to marketing and consumer behavior.

Folding tips into the meal tab has the benefit however of protecting waiters from being shortchanged by the occasional tight-fisted diner.

Gabriel Frem, owner of the upscale Brand 158 restaurant in the Los Angeles suburb of Glendale, also sees his establishment's no-tipping policy as a way to protect staff from the whims of diners.

"We interview and hire our employees, not the guest, and we expect to pay them, and be responsible for their actions," he said.

"If they do great, we keep them, and if they don't, we let them go.

We don't want their pay to be "at the mercy of a guest's random calculation, based on unpredictable factors."

Tips vary wildly

As it turns out, tipping can vary wildly from guest to guest -- and not always because of the quality of the table service.

Some patrons withhold tips because they feel the server was not sufficiently cheerful ("I don't like her smile.")

Others do so because they didn't particularly care for the food -- even if a meal's preparation is not under the control of the wait staff.

It's also a problem, Frem said, if workers don't know how much income they can count on from week to week. "We want to ensure that they can pay their bills," he said.

Some managers say greater pay security in tip-less restaurant reduces turnover and improves morale.

The tipless restaurant is still a long way from becoming the norm, but some New Yorkers are beginning to warm to the idea.

"At first, I really thought that if a waiter was rude, I would want my discontent to be reflected in their tip," said Noel Warren, a young New Yorker who dines out at least twice a week.

"But then I thought, why would a waiter be disrespectful in the first place? Probably because he or she has lost faith that customers are going to tip well -- so why put in any effort?"

Warren mused that it might in fact be fairer to take the decision about tips out of the fickle hands of restaurant patrons -- which might even improve the table service that patrons.

"If they were properly compensated for their work, they might treat their customers better," Warren said.

© 1994-2014 Agence France-Presse